Message-ID: <13994389.1075860467414.JavaMail.evans@thyme>
Date: Wed, 7 Feb 2001 04:55:00 -0800 (PST)
From: ayudkowsky@stroock.com
To: nolan.steiner@avistacorp.com, dvermillion@avistaenergy.com, 
	rmcmanus@bakerbotts.com, asettanni@bracepatt.com, 
	cgunter@bracepatt.com, dwatkiss@bracepatt.com, pfox@bracepatt.com, 
	rcarroll@bracepatt.com, jchen@brobeck.com, dmbutz@butzdunn.com, 
	andrzej_kabarowski@cargill.com, phillip_fantle@cargill.com, 
	psteele@coral-energy.com, kjohan@dwp.ci.la.ca.us, jmpa@dynegy.com, 
	joel.newton@dynegy.com, elizabeth.sager@enron.com, 
	mary.hain@enron.com, richard.b.sanders@enron.com, sstack@enron.com, 
	jheath@fulbright.com, jfrizzell@gibbs-bruns.com, 
	sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com, gkeltner@jsslaw.com, mghelms@jsslaw.com, 
	dpickett@mdbe.com, gerspamer@mofo.com, kirvin@mofo.com, 
	rloeffler@mofo.com, bcurrey@omm.com, jstamper@omm.com, 
	john.fryer@pacificorp.com, rbstrong@painehamblen.com, 
	thord@perkinscoie.com, jtiffany@pillsburywinthrop.com, 
	nancy.loftin@pinnaclewest.com, timothy.bolden@pinnaclewest.com, 
	dmperlman@poersrcc.com, rosteen@powersrc.com, awu@qeuo.com, 
	hao@quinnemanuel.com, drusso@reliantenergy.com, 
	mderstine@rhd-law.com, rheyman@rhd-law.com, dgarber@sempra.com, 
	wdsmith@sempra.com, rbeitler@sempratrading.com, aorchar@smud.org, 
	jdalfano@srpnet.com, paramfjord@stoel.com, rcjosephson@stoel.com, 
	mbrosterman@stroock.com, mgoldstein@stroock.com, 
	pjazayeri@stroock.com, theftler@stroock.com, 
	antoine.cobb@troutmansanders.com, cfr@vnf.com, gdb@vnf.com, 
	hes@vnf.com
Subject: Re: REVISED COMPLAINT
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
X-From: "ALAN YUDKOWSKY" <AYUDKOWSKY@stroock.com>
X-To: <nolan.steiner@avistacorp.com>, <dvermillion@avistaenergy.com>, <rmcmanus@bakerbotts.com>, <asettanni@bracepatt.com>, <cgunter@bracepatt.com>, <dwatkiss@bracepatt.com>, <pfox@bracepatt.com>, <rcarroll@bracepatt.com>, <JChen@brobeck.com>, <dmbutz@butzdunn.com>, <andrzej_kabarowski@cargill.com>, <phillip_fantle@cargill.com>, <psteele@coral-energy.com>, <kjohan@dwp.ci.la.ca.us>, <jmpa@dynegy.com>, <joel.newton@dynegy.com>, <elizabeth.sager@enron.com>, <mary.hain@enron.com>, <richard.b.sanders@enron.com>, <sstack@enron.com>, <jheath@fulbright.com>, <jfrizzell@gibbs-bruns.com>, <sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com>, <gkeltner@jsslaw.com>, <mghelms@jsslaw.com>, <dpickett@mdbe.com>, <gerspamer@mofo.com>, <kirvin@mofo.com>, <rloeffler@mofo.com>, <bcurrey@omm.com>, <jstamper@omm.com>, <john.fryer@pacificorp.com>, <rbstrong@painehamblen.com>, <thord@perkinscoie.com>, <jtiffany@pillsburywinthrop.com>, <nancy.loftin@pinnaclewest.com>, <Timothy.Bolden@pinnaclewest.com>, <DMPERLMAN@Poersrcc.com>, <rosteen@powersrc.com>, <awu@qeuo.com>, <hao@quinnemanuel.com>, <drusso@reliantenergy.com>, <mderstine@rhd-law.com>, <rheyman@rhd-law.com>, <dgarber@sempra.com>, <wdsmith@sempra.com>, <rbeitler@sempratrading.com>, <aorchar@smud.org>, <jdalfano@srpnet.com>, <paramfjord@stoel.com>, <rcjosephson@stoel.com>, "Melvin Brosterman" <MBROSTERMAN@stroock.com>, "Marvin Goldstein" <MGOLDSTEIN@stroock.com>, "PETER JAZAYERI" <PJAZAYERI@stroock.com>, "Tom Heftler" <THEFTLER@stroock.com>, <antoine.cobb@troutmansanders.com>, <cfr@vnf.com>, <gdb@vnf.com>, <hes@vnf.com>
X-cc: 
X-bcc: 
X-Folder: \Mary_Hain_Aug2000_Jul2001\Notes Folders\Notes inbox
X-Origin: Hain-M
X-FileName: mary-hain.nsf

Attached please find a revised version of the revised version together with a 
redline version of the proposed complaint.  We have incorporated many of 
Bracewell's changes but our approach, on behalf of Sempra Energy Trading, is 
to state the legal argument first (that the CalPX's use of the tariff is 
wrong) followed by the equitable argument that its doing so was unjust and 
unreasonable.  We feel that this presents a stronger argument for retroactive 
application.

Alan Z. Yudkowsky, Esq.
Stroock & Stroock & Lavan LLP
310-556-5829
310-556-5959 (fax)
ayudkowsky@stroock.com

>>> "Andrea Settanni" <asettanni@bracepatt.com> 02/07/01 06:41AM >>>
Attached please find a clean version and a redline version of the CalPX 
complaint.  The redline compares the version sent yesterday afternoon.  If 
you have any questions please contact Ron Carroll at 202-828-5872 or Andrea 
Settanni at 202-828-7631.  If you are interested in joining the complaint, 
please contact either Ron or Andrea by 1:00 pm today.  Thanks.

If anyone has email addresses for Douglas Thorpe, Fred Yanney, Katalin Kiss, 
and Sterling Koch, please forward this email.  Thank you.

Andrea M. Settanni
Bracewell & Patterson, L.L.P.
2000 K Street, N.W.
Suite 500
Washington, D.C.  20006-1872
(202) 828-7631 (phone)
(202) 857-2128 (fax)
asettanni@bracepatt.com

Attached documents:  50131010 v.3
Attached documents:  50131010 v.RED

 - 50131010.DOC